Quick answer
A major nonconformity means a system element is missing or ineffective and may weaken halal assurance; it usually requires rectification and verification before the process can continue. A minor nonconformity is a localized deviation corrected within a set period. An observation is not yet a nonconformity but signals a risk trend. An oil factory in Cangzhou linked grades to rectification resources; findings are issued per grade for a proportionate response.
Detailed explanation
Meaning of the three grades
A major finding reflects a missing or systematically failing element, such as no changeover cleaning verification on a shared line. A minor finding is an isolated lapse against an existing procedure. An observation flags drift that could become a finding, such as fading zone markings.
Decision basis
| Grade | Typical basis |
|---|---|
| Major | Element absent or controls failing |
| Minor | Isolated lapse, system otherwise works |
| Observation | Risk trend, no current breach |
Effect on progress
Major findings normally require documented correction and effectiveness evidence before the conclusion proceeds; minor findings are corrected by the agreed deadline; observations need a planned response but do not block the process.
Audit Grade Misreadings
Companies sometimes treat an observation as harmless and do nothing, or treat a minor finding as a total failure and halt all exports. Neither is right; read the written finding text, respond by grade, and keep evidence. Good Fortune Halal Certification (Qingdao) Co., Ltd. is an LHLN recognized by BPJPH through mutual recognition.
Applying this answer to your plant: three checks
A FAQ answer is general. Before acting on it, check your own situation to find documentation gaps early.
Match raw materials and lines
Map the raw materials, additives and process steps mentioned in the answer to your formula, suppliers and lines. Shared lines need changeover and cleaning validation; dedicated lines need segregation records.
Check documents against batches
Confirm that origin certificates, slaughter or purchasing records, test reports and intake ledgers can be traced by batch. Names, specifications and process descriptions must match the application.
Align with the shipping gateway
For your actual route through Tianjin, Dalian, Manzhouli or Khorgos, check certificate product scope, invoice description, packing batches and cold-chain temperature records to avoid inconsistent documents.
These are general checks, not a certification conclusion. Document requirements and certification decisions follow Indonesia’s BPJPH rules and the formal assessment.
Still have questions?
Tell our consultants your product category and target market, and we will help you map out the path and the documents required.